‘Cats Do Right Thing Re: Sina, Plus Bracket Busting

Jim Phillips ISO vs NEB 2012

Well, the initial fallout of the Bill Carmody firing is underway. Yesterday, Jerry Carino of NJ Hoops Haven (which I saw linked via SippinOnPurple) reported that Northwestern is releasing former commit, pg Jaren Sina, from his national letter of intent. It was the right thing to do.  Holding a high school kid hostage to a commitment made to a previous coach is the type of thing that some schools do and in my opinion, that is about the last thing we should be doing in this situation.  While Sina’s father did not mince words in advance of the potential Carmody axe falling down, I think many of us were hoping he’d at least consider the new Wildcat coach to be.

Well, Nick Medline of Scout.com’s PurpleWildcats.com was tweeting yesterday that Sina is exploring many schools and there is “no leader”.  We knew this was a distinct possibility, but it sure doesn’t make it easier to take. I’ll still hold out a glimmer of hope that our coach to be is going to be such a dynamic recruiter that he can retain Sina, but if he can’t, so be it. This isn’t a one year, two year or likely even three year rebuilding project.  Kudos to Jim Phillips for doing the right thing.

AD of The Year Finalist

Sports Business Journal announced its annual AD of the year finalists yesterday and Jim Phillps was named one of the final five.  We’ll keep you posted.

Buffalo Basketball Similarities

Thanks to Willie. W. for forwarding THIS link about University of Buffalo and the firing of Reggie Witherspoon. No, Reggie is not likely a candidate for NU. However, the striking similarities to the Carmody firing are too much to overlook.  Witherspoon went 14-20 after the best four year run in recent Buffalo hoops history.  He graduated (while NU lost them to injury) several starters and it was year 14 of his tenure. Nothing crazy, but just seemed very similar in many ways.

Bracket Madness

If you want a good bracket, don’t do as I do.  I somehow find my bracket taking control of me and then I end up with a Final Four that I say, how the heck did I get here? My Final Four? Miami, Florida, Michigan State, Ohio State. That’s right, not a single 1-seed, which is blasphemy based on recent years.   I get too emotionally attached to a)great storylines b)teams I’ve seen play a lot and c)Providence College connections.

Ironically, as “wild” as my Final Four is, I didn’t pick many upsets throughout the earlier rounds. I have 11-seed Bucknell (music tone…Northwestern coaching watch) upsetting 6-seed Butler.  I’ve got likely the wrong 12-5 as I do every year and other than that, it is chalk city. Until the Elite Eight.  I went with Miami because I’m loving the seniority on the team and Jim Larranaga (PC graduate).  I went with Florida because I love Billy Donovan (PC grad) and am buds with assistant coach Rashon Burno (more on him tomorrow).  I went with Sparty because I think they have the ingredients to make a run and I’ve seen them the most of any B1G team this year. Ohio State, well, it just kind of ended up that way.  I’m excited to hear more about your picks.

The LTP Tourney Pool (that is the group name) is up for you to join at ESPN.com.  We’ll be tracking the results throughout the Tournament, which technically begins tonight in Dayton.

 

 

  • NorthwesternState

    What’s the ESPN Pool password

    • Jason

      gatorbowlchamps

  • Smolmania

    gatorbowlchamps

  • cece

    oooh my, today’s front page of the sports section Tribune article on facilities…..

    • NU68

      Not all negative … Except that JP doesn’t plan to do anything about it until at least 2015.

    • PDXCat

      Any way to read that article for free?

      • cece

        don’t know. it was on the front page of the printed tribune, so might be on web.

      • http://twitter.com/LakeThePosts Lake The Posts

        Nope.

      • Kafkaesque

        Hey, PDX. You want good content? Pay for it. In the long run, paywalls — which fund real reporting, and real news-gathering — are much less expensive than, for example, ill-advised military actions in Iraq cheered on by an obedient, defanged press.

    • http://twitter.com/LakeThePosts Lake The Posts

      Tribune’s paywall drives me crazy.

    • http://twitter.com/LakeThePosts Lake The Posts

      Will include photo shot of Tribune…paper version..it was HUGE.

  • FloridAlum

    Hey, LTP, I just signed up for the Tourney Pool. You may concede now if you wish.

    • http://twitter.com/LakeThePosts Lake The Posts

      I think i did when I hit “publish”!

  • Mark

    I don’t believe Jim Delany’s affidavit in the O’Bannon litigation where he states Big Ten schools would essentially drop athletic scholarships and become the Midwest Ivy League if the NCAA loses the litigation. I’ve seen lying in litigation – and plenty of it – but this is the topper. Right, OSU and UofM and Nebraska and PSU are going to drop big time football if the schools can’t keep 100% of the money they bring in by selling items specific to individual athletics. The fact that he’d swear to it makes him look ridiculous.

    • Mark

      Yes, the Evanston YMCA could come back on NU’s schedule according to Delany. I hope he is called to testify.

      • YMCwho

        We don’t want to over strengthen our schedule given that we only have a one in eight chance of
        beating them.

    • Chasmo

      You hit the nail on the head — a laughable statement from an arrogant man who feels he can say anything he wants without being challenged. Image if Walmart’s CEO had said it would return to a local mom & pop operation if the federal minimum wage was increased to $10 an hour. Jeez.
      Delaney is worried that if players get a few thousand dollars each every year for generating billions in revenue, the money might come out of the salaries of coaches, athletic directors, recruiting budgets, and, oh yes, conference commissioners.
      It is immoral that kids must sign away the rights to their own images seen in video games or school advertising in order to play college football — especially since these kids are unable to turn pro until they have worked as indentured servants for the NCAA for three years. My goodness.

    • http://twitter.com/LakeThePosts Lake The Posts

      Yeah, that was pretty bad. Seems like a veiled threat..

  • NUinVa

    you’ll have to have a poll of the best bracket names – my vote goes to “Fire Carm… wait, what?” so far.

  • Noah

    I think we did the right thing with Sina. The situation changed and he deserves the opportunity to re-evaluate. I hope he chose NU for more reasons than Carmody, and he will continue to want to be a Wildcat and be even more committed to the journey, but as you said, its called “rebuilding” for a reason.

    • PDXCat

      Rebuilding?!?! I thought the next coach was just going to step right in and magically take us to the NCAAs in his first year, second at the VERY latest.

      • Mark

        Nobody said that and many of us said there was no guarantee things would get better. If the wrong person is picked it will get worse. But try to stick to the facts instead of making up straw man arguments.

        • Kafkaesque

          Easy, brother. To my eye, PDXCat’s rhetorical device here is more hyperbole than straw man, both of which are preferable to Noah’s quasi-tautology (“it’s called ‘rebuilding’ for a reason”).

  • hudhaifa3

    Wildcat Hoops left for DEAD!!!! We will be ok…Chris Collins is banging on the door….(pfftttt)

    • virginiaNU

      what a change from all the ncaa tourneys we’ve gone to in the last 100 years

  • Mark

    196 of the 899 players in the NCAA Men’s Tournament are from states with Big Ten schools. This may overrate recruitment potential as the Philly area has not traditionally been a Big Ten recruitment area. But nonetheless it shows the potential recruits who are capable of playing for tournament eligible schools. Got to believe that some of them would have been both academically eligible and interested in the Cats. (Database on Indianapolis Star website.)

    • bd005

      Why?

      They aren’t interested in playing hoops for PSU and UNL which have no academic barriers, much better facilities and a big sports culture.

      So what coaching hire, assuming he will run a more typical scheme, will be able to recruit the players that can compete athletically – enough to finish in the top 6-7 of the conf. (make that top 7-8 once UMD and RU join)?