Senior Night blues — Penn State stays ahead

ReggieHearnPennState030813

The odds were always against Reggie Hearn from even playing in a Big Ten game. His sophomore year, fans would chant his name just hoping for him to come into the game. No one imagined then he would be able to score. No imagined then all he would give to the program.

Hearn’s career might always be dotted with those “What Ifs?” What if Hearn had been given the opportunity early on in his career? Would he have been the scrappy guard that could help Northwestern get over the top with some of those John Shurna-Michael Thompson teams.

On a more micro level: What if Hearn had been available at the end of Northwestern’s 66-59 loss to Penn State on Thursday. Would he have been able to will the Wildcats in any way and finally get them over the hump? What if he had not fouled out?

Score Off. Rtg. eFG% O.Reb.% TO% FTR
Penn State 66 103.1 56.7 34.8 22.2 55.6
Northwestern 59 86.3 42.9 15.4 20.7 38.8

Above are statistics known as the Four Factors and are regarded as indicative contributors to wins and losses. Please see the end of this post for an explanation.

Hearn was emotional as he walked off the Welsh-Ryan Arena floor with his teammates still fighting. He was leaving the game much earlier than he or anyone else could have anticipated. He had given it his all, using every foul and every moment he could. His team was not able to back him and Alex Marcotullio up to send this senior class off with a victory.

Hearn scored 11 points and grabbed five rebounds. Alex Marcotullio had a career night with 22 points on 6-for-9 shooting from beyond the arc. They did all they could. It was not enough.

Northwestern gave up the first 12 points of the game, stormed back to tie the game at 30 and then gave up the next 11 points to dig the team a hole it was struggling to climb out of the entire evening. Northwestern tried with Dave Sobolewski, Hearn and Marcotullio making plays to keep the team within striking distance.

It seemed though every time the Wildcats would climb within four the Nittany Lions would find a way to pull back away. Much like the four years Hearn and Marcotullio spent at Northwestern, the team came so close only to fall short.

The stakes were much lower however against Penn State though. All that was left it seemed was pride and the memories of the final game at Welsh-Ryan Arena.

Northwestern again continued to struggle offensively. Turnovers plagued the beginning of the game and the Wildcats finished with 15 in the game including five from Marcotullio and four from Dave Sobolewski. NU also shot 34.7 percent from the floor, relying on free throws to stay in the game much of the way.

Many players NU needed to step up on the offensive end simply could not buy a shot. Sobolewski was 2 for 10 from the floor for eight points. Alex Olah scored only five points on 2-for-7 shooting, missing a few shots close to the basket. Tre Demps was 2 for 7 as well. Northwestern could not get key shots to fall and that is the basic motto for this team — Make Shots.

Northwestern slowly got better breaking down the 2-3 zone Penn State used most of the night, but the team could not get enough momentum going to overtake Penn State.

The Nittany Lions shot 48.9 percent and 15 of 25 free throws, getting 18 points apiece from Jermaine Marshall and D.J. Newbill. The Nittany Lions had eight offensive rebounds and did a great job breaking down the Wildcats’ defense.

Penn State had he ability to stymie Northwestern when it needed to. The Nittany Lions were flying around and showing a lot of heart for a team sitting at 1-15 in the Big Ten.

Again, it seemed the Wildcats were game to give a good college try at getting this win. The execution and ability to score simply were not there.

Like Hearn and Marcotullio, NU seemed to give the game everything it had. And like most of this season, it ended in bitter disappointment. It felt like those seniors deserved much better.

Offensive Rating measures points scored per 100 possessions.
Effective field goal percentage measures field goal percentage taking into account the added value of a 3-point shot.
Offensive rebound percentage measures the percentage of offensive rebounds over total rebounds.
Turnover percentage estimates what percentage of a team’s possessions end in a turnover.
Free throw rate measures the rate of free throw attempts over field goal attempts.

  • bt

    The remaining few defending Carmody at this point are doing it only because of pride and ego. Not sure how anybody in their right mind can consistently watch a team go :32 seconds into a shot clock without ever getting within 20 feet of the basket before throwing up a wild 3 pointer or have their tiny PG posted up/ rebounded against on the defensive glass and think everything is ok.

    The bar must be raised. The standards have to change. This level of consistent failure would not work in the business world. It definitely does not work in the sports world. After 13 years it has been long enough that all sides should be able to say thank you for your efforts, but it is time to move on.

    • bd005

      So – should the standards have been changed for the gridiron ‘Cats when they totally collapsed after Persa (ONE player) went down in the Iowa game?
      Aside from this past season due to injuries, the BB and FB programs have had comparable level of success over the previous 4 seasons (esp. taking into account that the B1G has been the best or 2nd best conf. in CBB over those years while in CFB it had been 3rd or 4th best).

  • Alaskawildcat

    At this point the focus could well be on the Big Ten Tournament. Rest the players, avoid injury and save the best for last. Improbable though it might be, that is our one remaining window for getting into the Big Dance.

    • DR

      Uh, can I get some of whatever it is you are enjoying up there in Alaska?

  • Nucat99

    I made the mistake of watching the second half. If not for Alex, we would have been blown out. Worse than that, I saw no emotion from anyone not graduating. I have been all aboard the rollercoaster that has been NU basketball over the last few years. It’s time for a change.

    Btw- anyone else think a High school game gym would be louder than W-R last night? Even students aren’t showing up. Sad.

    • Chasmo

      I, too, saw a lack of intensity from the Cats in what was a winnable game. Carmody’s inability to get his kids to play hard and with confidence is the main reason — after his inability to recruit — it might be time for him to go.
      Penn State, despite its lousy record, played hard. NU, despite playing at home on senior night, did not. While NU, PSU, and Nebraska are all bad teams, only NU consistently lacks intensity in the season’s final weeks.
      Some NU fans fear that if Carmody is fired, Crawford with transfer ala Swopshire to play right away, Cobb will transfer back home ala Prater to play right away, and Jeren Sina will ask for his release to play somewhere else. So they want Carmody to stay.
      Others share those fears but still want Carmody gone so suggest promoting Hardy to keep C&C and keeping Hill on the staff to keep Sina.

      The rest believe that only a new staff can bring the type new attitude these kids need.
      Let’s see which faction JIm Phillips joins after the next two losses.

      • PDXCat

        Where do you stand? Seems if you’re making a break, you need to make a break. While you may lose guys, it’s a year’s worth of Drew, Cobb lost (and whoever else). And is a Sina commitment expendable if the assumption is the new guy can get Sina+? I flop between the 3 camps regularly

        • Chasmo

          I share your POV but I feel about Carmody the same way I do about abortion: both sides make good points.
          If NU keeps Carmody, it still might struggle into the 2014 NIT despite having Olah at center and no power forward. But how well will recruiting go this fall if it’s clear that Carmody has been given one more season to prove himself — especially since Carmody is a lousy recruiter in the best of circumstances?
          When NU hired Randy Walker, a lot of talented Gary Barnett era players left and had they stayed NU would have been a much better team. But Walker did win the 2000 Big Ten title with a team comprised mostly of Barnett recruits.
          Even if one or two kids leaves, firing Carmody sends the message that NU expects to win in basketball. That message will resonate with recruits, providing NU hires a recruiter as coach.
          I do understand the “keep Carmody” point of view but I feel the majority of those folks who take that stance do so because they feel hoops is a lost cause and Carmody is the best NU can do.

  • PurpleHayes

    Sorry I missed the post yesterday about the seniors (sorry about last night too–ugh!). But while it’s a struggle to find any positives from the home schedule this season, here’s one that will be my favorite Reggie Hearn memory. As Reggie darted down the lane for a lay-up and his twenty-first point at the end of his amazing first half against Purdue, the two disgusted but vocal Boilermakers sitting behind us groaned (again), and one of them said: “This kid’s from Fort Wayne, and we didn’t offer him a scholarship because of WHY?” Reggie, you proved them all wrong and did us proud at a very humbling time. Way to go.

  • Pittsburgh Wildcat

    Sure seems like Carmody’s postgame comments (the issue of coming back next year has been “on his mind” lately) could be an early indicator that everyone knows it is time.

    Teddy G in the Trib had a good comparison. He said this is feeling like Illinois’ situation with Bruce Weber last year where the Illini folded in the 2nd half of the season (2-12 after a 15-3 start) and they had no choice but to part ways with Weber.

    Assuming we lose at Sparty then lose in the 6/11 game in the B1G Tourney, that’s NU closing the season with 9 straight losses and losses in 11 of the final 12 games.