Athlon Sports ranks the college coaching jobs, Northwestern No. 63

Fitz ISO vs NEB 2012

Wednesday afternoon, Athlon Sports released its rankings of the top coaching jobs in the nation. Yes, the top of the list is filled with the typical “names” and traditional powers. Northwestern did not have a hope of being named one of the top jobs. And the Wildcats job is pretty much nailed down for the next eternity while Pat Fitzgerald still wants to coach.

Still lists like these from one of the major college football publications tends to serve as a bit of a litmus test for how far Northwestern has come as a football program and whether it is gaining national respect.

Certainly going to five straight bowl games, being bowl eligible for six straight years and winning the first bowl game in 64 years has done enough to raise Northwestern’s profile? The Wildcats certainly would not be in the 100s like they might have been back in the Dark Days in the 1980s. You can certainly win at Northwestern now. And Fitzgerald has done an amazing job increasing the talent level with each successive recruiting class and the facilities are coming.

So where does Northwestern rank?

Athlon has them No. 63 . . . behind Vanderbilt (No. 62), Kansas (No. 61) and even Minnesota (No. 56). It seems Northwestern still has a perception gap to fight among the national media. Here is what Athlon wrote of the job:

 

As the only private school in the Big Ten, Northwestern can be an attractive option for a top-flight recruit from the Midwest who is looking for an elite academic institution. The university has recently approved a $225-250 million facilities overhaul for all of the athletic programs. Football will no doubt be a huge beneficiary. However, no matter how much money is pumped into the program, Northwestern will always struggle to keep up with the elite programs in the Big Ten, from a recruiting and facilities standpoint. You can win at Northwestern, but it will always be a challenge.

 

It seems like Athlon is going with the “no way they can be consistent with this winning thing” mentality with Northwestern. Even though Vanderbilt has less winning tradition and even stiffer competition in the SEC (not to mention two losses to Northwestern in the last three years and the mark of shame from backing out of the contract to play the fellow private school).

I mean, Illinois cracked the top-50. Sure the Illini may have the resources but what have they done with it? That program is an utter wreck and has been nothing but disappointment since that Rose Bowl trip we never speak of.

Athlon ranks Northwestern 11th in the Big Ten ahead of only Indiana.

The Wildcats program certainly presents a unique challenge. They have those academic standards to overcome but Pat Fitzgerald has largely done it and has created a consistent program where winning is no longer something nice, but expected. It is hard to imagine Northwestern having a season where it is not in bowl contention, if not in a bowl game. Fitzgerald has built the program to that level. And the administration is fully behind him and his program as signified by that large investment in Ryan Fieldhouse.

That is certainly a lot more than can be said at Minnesota, Illinois or even Purdue right now. Even with all those supposed advantages that they have over Northwestern.

Sure sounds like Athlon needs to rethink its perception of Northwestern. I guess winning is the only way to do that. Good thing Pat Fitzgerald is here to stay and we will not have to worry about filling that post for some time.

  • Stephen Zgrabik

    I read that article and was disappointed at how low we were in the Big 10. I didn’t expect to be at the top, but with the support the administration has been showing recently (most recently with the $200+ million facilities), I thought we’d have been higher. If they took each school’s athletic director (or VP of Athletics) into account, I bet we would have been higher.

    • NU68

      Every once in a while reality rears its head …..

    • Palo Alto Wildcat

      How did Stanford rank in the Athlon report? It has comparable academic standards to Northwestern but I don’t know if it holds their football player’s to the same academic standards set for other students. Do you know?

    • http://www.facebook.com/noahkimmel Noah Kimmel

      Im confident in JP, Fitz, the team, the upgrades, the trajectory, the fans, etc.

      Let the haters hate, we are in the drivers seat, and we will go to a B1G Championship game.

  • Chasmo

    Athlon’s ranking makes sense if all that matters is winning and getting paid but it is overlooking some very important factors that make Northwestern one of the best jobs in college football.
    NU is considered an unattractive job because: 1. academic restrictions limit recruiting; 2. a private school has a smaller alumni/fan base and so fewer kids from Illinois grow up dreaming to play for NU; 3. Chicago’s cold weather makes it less attractive to some recruits; 4. NU can’t pay its coach $3+ million a year.
    But if working conditions are factored in, NU is a great job because it offers job security: 1. NU will never fire a coach who can win more games than he loses (and in Bill Carmody’s case, not even if he doesn’t); 2. its fans have “realistic” expectations (see how many want to keep Carmody) so a coach’s seat won’t get hot; 3. NU recruit kids with good character and academics so babysitting and damage control is not a major part of the job; 4. the media spotlight is much less bright than it is in other jobs as Chicago media has bought into the “reasonable expectations” point of view and does not cover NU with the same intensity that it covers Notre Dame and Illinois; 5. the team has become a consistent winner and a new facility will make recruiting easier; 6. working for NU still makes you a multi-millionaire and allows you to buy a nice house in a beautiful suburb right outside one of America’s great cities.
    I see why Athlon is down on NU but NU is a lot better job than it thinks. I have to think that poor Gary Barnett wishes he had never left — especially now that the odious AD Rick Taylor is long gone — because he certainly would still be a major conference football coach today if he had stayed.

  • Carlton

    If you look at the list, it’s essentially a list of “where do you have a best chance to win?” We like to think about all the intangibles, and to us it’s nonsensical that someone would prefer to live in West Lafayette, Indiana, or deal with complete thugs on a daily basis, or work under a regime that is so obsessed with W-L that you’re gone after a single disappointing season. But I don’t think the list really considered the intangibles.

    But regardless, it’s nice to know that this list is really only of hypothetical significance. Our coach is going nowhere, any time soon.

  • NUARANINETYFIVE

    No need to be verbose here, Athlon is wrong. In Northwestern’s history, the job has attracted Pappy Waldorf, Ara Parseghian, Alex Agase, Gary Barnett & now Pat Fitzgerald. Northwestern is a football school, Illinois is not. Looking at the entire history of both football programs, any ranking agency that puts the Illini ahead of NU both for head coach appeal or overall program rankings is simply wrong. The reality since ’95 has been the opposite of the perception that still exists amongst the ‘experts’ and is reflective of a singular, narrow mind-set.
    Northwestern is the most conseqential losing program in the history of BCS football. We beat Minnesota when that meant something. We stopped Oklahoma’s streak. We beat Cal in the Rose Bowl. We beat ND four times in a row. Our nickname is derived from the fierce play against an unstoppable Michigan team. Just like Northwestern football was on the rise 100 years ago with Paddy Driscoll…so too is the program now. Who cares what Athlon thinks. They are wrong.

  • CatAlum06

    This is about as useful as trying to rank the best majors or industries. There’s no such thing as “the best”. There are different people with certain skillsets suited for different jobs. Fitz is uniquely suited for the Northwestern job in a way no other coach is. No ranking is ever going to reflect that.

  • Go Cats!

    Next time all you Fitz haters drone on an on about how we need to get a big time coach in here – remember this list. It’s a tough gig – and we’ve got the perfect fit in our current guy even if he’s not perfect.

  • rararawrgocats

    Maryland is 17 spots ahead of NU?! That seems like a bit of a slap in the face.

  • http://www.northwesternmix.com/ NUMBSpiritLeader

    The ranking sounds like it is about coaching position – not coach per se. I can understand why NU would get a relatively low ranking as a coaching position. But what’s more important is that NU has the #1 RIGHT coach for the position.